It was a disappointing scene that I witness today in class.
To start off on the issue of courage, the power invested in the CMC to take charge of the class on behalf of the teachers was not applied nor exercised with courage. I would like that all CMC to display more moral courage in your action rather than just speech. It is only through your action that separate the leaders from the mass. As for the rest of the class, not one person stood up to take responsibility of being a sideline observer without taking any preventive measure for the escalation of the spat.
Next, the absence of dignity during the squabble. The trouble perpetrators; Shan Yao and Ryan, and to a lesser degree, Zi Yang and Edward, these people failed to show any dignity in restraining their selfish impulses, childishness and uncontrollable anger. Shan Yao and Ryan permitted the escalation of the quarrel by not clarifying the situation for Zi Yang and Edward. Both of Shan Yao and Ryan are the root of the problem and contributed entirely to the intensification of the already negative situation.
Lastly, would it be too much to determine that Sec 1O is a loveless class; a pack of cannibalistic
predators, a pack of hounds? From this incident, it is evident that there is no evidence to indicate otherwise.From this incident, would Sec 1O learn to be more courageous, dignified and loving? Would you be a class that I am proud of? Or a class that I would rather not be associated with?
I leave the decision to you.
2 comments:
Sry Mr Krison I just can't stand it when ppl push the blame on me like as if i'm a thrashcan for them.
You said "The trouble perpetrators; Shan Yao and Ryan, and to a lesser degree, Zi Yang and Edward".
I beg to differ. In my opinion, even though Shan Yao and Ryan may have been the root of the problem, Zi Yang and Edward caused the "eruption".
Shan Yao and Ryan were wrong, sure, but I feel that Zi Yang was wrong to explode like that too.
Shan Yao and Ryan, in my opinion, were not as much to blame, except for the fact of starting it all.
They could have been dealt with quietly, without all the hullabaloo caused by Zi Yang's needless explosion.
I feel that he needs to try and restrain himself at times.
If he did not throw the paper ball, why get so enraged about it? He should just have explained it nicely to Jia Hao, and leave the decision up to Jia Hao whether to believe him or not.
I is Zi Yang's fault for exploding and yelling at Edward. Edward also should have controlled himself more, but the level of control to me, compared to Zi Yang's, was remarkable.
Zi Yang hurled the piece of paper at Edward, but Edward did not respond in kind.
I'm sorry, but I think Zi Yang and Edward are as guilty as Shan Yao and Ryan
Yours respectfully,
Samuel Dalby, from as unbiased a view as possible
Post a Comment